The verdict at a glance
Fathom scores higher overall (71 to 70), but the right pick depends on what you weight.
Fathom is a cloud management reporting, KPI analysis, three-way forecasting and consolidation tool from The Access Group, built for accounting firms and small to mid-sized businesses that run Xero, QuickBooks Online or MYOB.
Spotlight Reporting is a New Zealand suite of management reporting, three-way forecasting, dashboards and multi-entity consolidation that accounting firms and small to mid-sized groups run on top of Xero, QuickBooks, MYOB and Sage ledgers.
Quick facts
- Fathom AF score. 71/100
- Fathom implementation. Low
- Fathom best fit. Firms and SMBs on Xero, QBO, MYOB
- Spotlight Reporting AF score. 70/100
- Spotlight Reporting implementation. Low
- Spotlight Reporting best fit. Advisory firms on Xero, QBO, Sage
Dimension by dimension
- Compliance depth. Fathom 57, Spotlight Reporting 66. Edge: Spotlight Reporting.
- Scalability. Fathom 61, Spotlight Reporting 62. Edge: Spotlight Reporting.
- AI / agent readiness. Fathom 28, Spotlight Reporting 30. Edge: Spotlight Reporting.
- Support. Fathom 81, Spotlight Reporting 80. Edge: Fathom.
- Implementation. Fathom 77, Spotlight Reporting 74. Edge: Fathom.
- Pricing transparency. Fathom 86, Spotlight Reporting 82. Edge: Fathom.
- Modeling depth. Fathom 52, Spotlight Reporting 58. Edge: Spotlight Reporting.
- ERP & data connectivity. Fathom 64, Spotlight Reporting 67. Edge: Spotlight Reporting.
Pick Fathom if
- Accounting firms producing monthly branded management reports for 10 to 50 Xero, QuickBooks Online or MYOB clients
- Franchise groups and multi-entity small businesses that need consolidations with eliminations and franchisee benchmarking
- Owner-managed businesses that want a monthly three-way forecast and KPI tracking without maintaining it in Excel
Pick Spotlight Reporting if
- Accounting firms on Xero or QuickBooks that want to sell monthly report packs and cash flow forecasts across 10 to 75 clients, with vendor-led training
- Groups of up to 75 entities that need multi-currency consolidated reports and forecasts with intercompany eliminations
- Franchise head offices and not-for-profit networks that benchmark and rank many entities in Spotlight Multi
Further reading
Keep exploring
Both reviews are updated on a rolling cycle by our research agents.