The verdict at a glance
IBM Planning Analytics scores higher overall (76 to 76), but the right pick depends on what you weight.
IBM Planning Analytics is an enterprise planning platform on the TM1 in-memory engine, used by large finance teams for budgets, forecasts and workforce plans in Excel or on the web, sold as SaaS on IBM Cloud, AWS or Azure, or installed on premises.
Jedox is a German planning platform built on an in-memory multidimensional database, with an Excel 365 add-in and a browser spreadsheet, sold to mid-market and enterprise finance teams for budgeting, forecasting and consolidation.
Quick facts
- IBM Planning Analytics AF score. 76/100
- IBM Planning Analytics implementation. High
- IBM Planning Analytics best fit. Large Excel-first enterprise FP&A
- Jedox AF score. 76/100
- Jedox implementation. Medium
- Jedox best fit. Excel-first, multi-entity FP&A
Dimension by dimension
- Compliance depth. IBM Planning Analytics 78, Jedox 81. Edge: Jedox.
- Scalability. IBM Planning Analytics 86, Jedox 77. Edge: IBM Planning Analytics.
- AI / agent readiness. IBM Planning Analytics 80, Jedox 67. Edge: IBM Planning Analytics.
- Support. IBM Planning Analytics 66, Jedox 74. Edge: Jedox.
- Implementation. IBM Planning Analytics 60, Jedox 71. Edge: Jedox.
- Pricing transparency. IBM Planning Analytics 72, Jedox 69. Edge: IBM Planning Analytics.
- Modeling depth. IBM Planning Analytics 88, Jedox 85. Edge: IBM Planning Analytics.
- ERP & data connectivity. IBM Planning Analytics 62, Jedox 75. Edge: Jedox.
Pick IBM Planning Analytics if
- Enterprises with large multidimensional driver models (many products, cost centers or SKUs) that have outgrown Excel and need on-demand recalculation
- Finance teams that want to keep Excel as the front end through PAfE while one governed model holds the data and security
- SAP shops and existing TM1 customers who want governed AI agents working on the same cubes
Pick Jedox if
- A European or DACH group that wants Excel-style planning and statutory consolidation under IFRS, HGB or US GAAP from one vendor.
- An SAP or Salesforce shop that wants plans fed from SAP extracts and sales targets written back into Salesforce objects.
- A finance team of 5 to 10 seats that wants a published entry price and can buy the Business or Professional package through AWS Marketplace.
Further reading
Keep exploring
Both reviews are updated on a rolling cycle by our research agents.