The verdict
Planful
AF score 76 / 100 · Leads on 6 of 8Choose it if
- A multi-entity group that wants planning and consolidation in one platform without hiring a team of model builders
- A NetSuite, Sage Intacct or Dynamics 365 shop moving budgets, close packs and board decks off spreadsheets
- A finance team already working in Claude that wants governed, read-only answers from plan and actuals data
Prophix
AF score 76 / 100 · Leads on 2 of 8Choose it if
- A mid-market group with many legal entities that wants budgeting, consolidation and reconciliations on one data set
- A finance team on NetSuite, Sage Intacct, Acumatica or Dynamics 365 Finance & Operations
- Healthcare, senior living or higher education finance teams that need HITRUST, an industry template and personnel planning by employee
Scores from our independent reviews of both tools. Prices verified 12 Nov 2026.
At a glance
| Fact | Planful | Prophix |
|---|
| Best fit | Multi-entity planning and close | Mid-market multi-entity finance |
| Price | ~$40.4k/yr median contract (Vendr) | ~$205.5k/yr avg, 5 deals (Vendr) |
| Pricing model | Quote only: annual subscription by users and modules | Quote only: annual subscription by license level and modules |
| Implementation | Medium | Medium |
| Time to go live | 8 to 12 weeks (reported) | 8 to 16 weeks (vendor) |
| Agent readiness | 3 / 5 | ✓ 4 / 5 |
| AF score | 76 / 100 | 76 / 100 |
✓ marks a clear edge. Prices are as each vendor publishes them, verified 12 Nov 2026.
AF scores by dimension
PlanfulProphix
Planful leads on
ERP & data connectivity
+6Each dimension is scored 0 to 100 in the full reviews. The chip shows the leader's margin.
What each costs
Planful
~$40.4k/yr median contract (Vendr)
Quote only: annual subscription by users and modules
Prophix
~$205.5k/yr avg, 5 deals (Vendr)
Quote only: annual subscription by license level and modules
Compare plans on their own sitesNeither vendor pays us. Both buttons go to the vendor's own site.
Where each falls short
Planful is a weak fit for
- A team that wants AI agents to write back to the plan
- A buyer who needs list prices before a sales call
- An Excel-first team that wants to keep modeling in workbooks
Prophix is a weak fit for
- Teams that want published per-seat prices before they talk to sales
- Excel-first shops on Mac or Excel Online
- Buyers who need an AI agent outside Prophix to write budgets back today
Planful vs Prophix: common questions
Which scores higher, Planful or Prophix?
They tie at 76 out of 100.
How much do Planful and Prophix cost?
Planful: ~$40.4k/yr median contract (Vendr). Prophix: ~$205.5k/yr avg, 5 deals (Vendr).
How long does each take to go live?
Planful: 8 to 12 weeks (reported). Prophix: 8 to 16 weeks (vendor).
Which works better with AI agents?
Planful rates 3 and Prophix rates 4 out of 5 on our agent-readiness test.
Decided?Or ask us about your setup below.
Keep exploring
Ask AFStill deciding? Ask about this matchup.
A straight answer from our research on both tools.